Two years ago, Orwellian sci-fi RPG Paranoia: Happiness is Mandatory was removed from sale within weeks of its release. The reason for its delisting has remained a mystery, but a set of court documents unearthed by Gamekult may shed light on the situation.
The court documents detail a complaint lodged by publisher Bigben Interactive, AKA Nacon, against Paranoia’s rights-holders in October of 2021. Greg Costikyan and Eric Goldberg, two of the creators of the Paranoia tabletop RPG, are named in the complaint, which is apparently about a breach of a license agreement.
Gamekult has access to the defendants’ brief, and the gist of their defense seems to be this: Costikyan and Goldberg were contractually allowed to inspect a pre-release version of the videogame based on their creation, in which they reported finding bugs both large and small (apparently listing 74 of them). They requested the game be delayed, rather than releasing in its current state and potentially damaging the Paranoia brand. Nacon, which had already delayed its release multiple times, went ahead and published it anyway.
Costikyan and Goldberg, unhappy having their brand associated with the videogame, asked Nacon to withdraw it from sale. When the publisher refused, they went directly to Epic with a DMCA request (Paranoia: Happiness is Mandatory had a 12-month exclusivity deal with the Epic Games Store), explaining they were still the owners of the intellectual property. As a result, the game was withdrawn from sale on January 24, 2020.
The court case is ongoing, with the most recent document, which is from Friday, granting an extension. I’ve reached out to both Eric Goldberg and Nacon, and will update if I receive a reply.
Nacon has also been involved in a contractual dispute with developer Frogwares over The Sinking City, with Frogwares using a DMCA takedown to get their own game removed from Steam after claiming that Nacon had uploaded a “cracked and pirated” version of it without permission.
Jody’s first computer was a Commodore 64, so he remembers having to use a code wheel to play Pool of Radiance. A former music journalist who interviewed everyone from Giorgio Moroder to Trent Reznor, Jody also co-hosted Australia’s first radio show about videogames, Zed Games. He’s written for Rock Paper Shotgun, The Big Issue, GamesRadar, Zam, Glixel, and Playboy.com, whose cheques with the bunny logo made for fun conversations at the bank. Jody’s first article for PC Gamer was published in 2015, he edited PC Gamer Indie from 2017 to 2018, and actually did play every Warhammer videogame.
Earlier in this year, when Square Enix first announced its Pixel Remaster series, there was a sneaking suspicion that we’d get to see all the games in 2021. Unfortunately, that’s not going to be the case. In a tweet, which you can read by clicking here, Squeenix has revealed that the last game in the …
Home News (Image credit: Netflix) An unofficial Squid Game cryptocurrency called SQUID launched and vanished in less than a month. Its creators, whose identities are unknown, pulled the rug out from would-be investors after pocketing about $3.38 million. The SQUID crypto coin wasn’t officially affiliated with Squid Game, the popular Netflix show that debuted on …
The Apache Software Foundation on Thursday released additional security updates for its HTTP Server product to remediate what it says is an “incomplete fix” for an actively exploited path traversal and remote code execution flaw that it patched earlier this week. CVE-2021-42013, as the new vulnerability is identified as, builds upon CVE-2021-41773, a flaw that …
Screenshot: Nintendo Kraid is a good boy. I don’t know why he’s locked up in a room full of boiling lava in Metroid Dread, which arrived on the Switch last Friday, but he doesn’t deserve it. If you’re a monster who’s willing to make his life even more terrible, however, players recently discovered a much …
Home News (Image credit: HUM Images (Getty)) Electronic Arts, Gearbox, and Microsoft are among 65 companies who have signed a letter calling on Texas governor Greg Abbott to abandon his “anti-LGBTQ+ efforts,” in particular a directive that calls for the state’s Department of Family and Protective Services to classify medical treatments for transgender adolescents, including …
Image: Ubisoft / Kotaku Way back in 2004 a then-unknown developer called Crytek released the first game in what would become the Far Cry series, wowing players with its impressive visuals and sprawling, outdoor maps. Crytek moved on to creating the Crysis series, Ubisoft bought up Far Cry and continues to make new entries to …
Court Documents May Explain The Disappearance Of Paranoia: Happiness Is Mandatory
Two years ago, Orwellian sci-fi RPG Paranoia: Happiness is Mandatory was removed from sale within weeks of its release. The reason for its delisting has remained a mystery, but a set of court documents unearthed by Gamekult may shed light on the situation.
The court documents detail a complaint lodged by publisher Bigben Interactive, AKA Nacon, against Paranoia’s rights-holders in October of 2021. Greg Costikyan and Eric Goldberg, two of the creators of the Paranoia tabletop RPG, are named in the complaint, which is apparently about a breach of a license agreement.
Gamekult has access to the defendants’ brief, and the gist of their defense seems to be this: Costikyan and Goldberg were contractually allowed to inspect a pre-release version of the videogame based on their creation, in which they reported finding bugs both large and small (apparently listing 74 of them). They requested the game be delayed, rather than releasing in its current state and potentially damaging the Paranoia brand. Nacon, which had already delayed its release multiple times, went ahead and published it anyway.
Costikyan and Goldberg, unhappy having their brand associated with the videogame, asked Nacon to withdraw it from sale. When the publisher refused, they went directly to Epic with a DMCA request (Paranoia: Happiness is Mandatory had a 12-month exclusivity deal with the Epic Games Store), explaining they were still the owners of the intellectual property. As a result, the game was withdrawn from sale on January 24, 2020.
The court case is ongoing, with the most recent document, which is from Friday, granting an extension. I’ve reached out to both Eric Goldberg and Nacon, and will update if I receive a reply.
Nacon has also been involved in a contractual dispute with developer Frogwares over The Sinking City, with Frogwares using a DMCA takedown to get their own game removed from Steam after claiming that Nacon had uploaded a “cracked and pirated” version of it without permission.
Jody’s first computer was a Commodore 64, so he remembers having to use a code wheel to play Pool of Radiance. A former music journalist who interviewed everyone from Giorgio Moroder to Trent Reznor, Jody also co-hosted Australia’s first radio show about videogames, Zed Games. He’s written for Rock Paper Shotgun, The Big Issue, GamesRadar, Zam, Glixel, and Playboy.com, whose cheques with the bunny logo made for fun conversations at the bank. Jody’s first article for PC Gamer was published in 2015, he edited PC Gamer Indie from 2017 to 2018, and actually did play every Warhammer videogame.
Related Posts
Final Fantasy VI Pixel Remaster Delayed Until Next Year
Earlier in this year, when Square Enix first announced its Pixel Remaster series, there was a sneaking suspicion that we’d get to see all the games in 2021. Unfortunately, that’s not going to be the case. In a tweet, which you can read by clicking here, Squeenix has revealed that the last game in the …
Squid Game Cryptocurrency Scammers Vanish With $3.3M
Home News (Image credit: Netflix) An unofficial Squid Game cryptocurrency called SQUID launched and vanished in less than a month. Its creators, whose identities are unknown, pulled the rug out from would-be investors after pocketing about $3.38 million. The SQUID crypto coin wasn’t officially affiliated with Squid Game, the popular Netflix show that debuted on …
New Patch Released For Actively Exploited 0-Day Apache Path Traversal To RCE Attacks
The Apache Software Foundation on Thursday released additional security updates for its HTTP Server product to remediate what it says is an “incomplete fix” for an actively exploited path traversal and remote code execution flaw that it patched earlier this week. CVE-2021-42013, as the new vulnerability is identified as, builds upon CVE-2021-41773, a flaw that …
Metroid Dread Players Discover Gnarly, Secret Way To Quick-Kill Kraid
Screenshot: Nintendo Kraid is a good boy. I don’t know why he’s locked up in a room full of boiling lava in Metroid Dread, which arrived on the Switch last Friday, but he doesn’t deserve it. If you’re a monster who’s willing to make his life even more terrible, however, players recently discovered a much …
Electronic Arts, Gearbox, And Microsoft Speak Out Against Anti-Trans Directive In Texas
Home News (Image credit: HUM Images (Getty)) Electronic Arts, Gearbox, and Microsoft are among 65 companies who have signed a letter calling on Texas governor Greg Abbott to abandon his “anti-LGBTQ+ efforts,” in particular a directive that calls for the state’s Department of Family and Protective Services to classify medical treatments for transgender adolescents, including …
Every Far Cry Game, Ranked From Worst To Best
Image: Ubisoft / Kotaku Way back in 2004 a then-unknown developer called Crytek released the first game in what would become the Far Cry series, wowing players with its impressive visuals and sprawling, outdoor maps. Crytek moved on to creating the Crysis series, Ubisoft bought up Far Cry and continues to make new entries to …